Don Mattingly
Year/Brand/Card Number/Book Value/Adjusted Value (less than Near Mint cards)/Sale Price/Quantity available. Most cards are for sale at 40%-60% off fair book value.
- 1985 Topps-All-Stars-Glossy #27/40 $2.50 $1.25
- 1986 Fleer-Baseball's Best-Sluggers #21/44 $.75 $.40
- 1986 Sportflics-Jumbo Discs-Coupon #NNO $1.25 $.65
- 1986 Topps #180 $1.25 $.30 $.15 EX *
- 1986 Topps-Box Panel Card #J $2.00 $.30 $.15 (2) VG *
- 1986 Topps-Mini League Leaders #28 $1.00 $.50 (6)
- 1986 Topps-Mini League Leaders #28 $1.00 $.40 $.20 EX-MT *
- 1987 Boardwalk & Baseball #32/33 $1.25 $.65 (2)
- 1987 Boardwalk & Baseball #32/33 $1.25 $.20 $.10 VG *
- 1987 Donruss #52 $1.25 $.65 (4)
- 1987 Donruss-Highlights #17 $.75 $.40
- 1987 Donruss-Highlights #23 $.75 $.40
- 1987 Donruss-Highlights #48 $.75 $.40
- 1987 Fleer-Award Winners #24/44 $.75 $.40
- 1987 Fleer-Baseball All-Stars #26/44 $.75 $.40 (4)
- 1987 Fleer-Baseball's Best-Sluggers #25/44 $.75 $.40
- 1987 Fleer-Game Winners #26/44 $.75 $.40
- 1987 Fleer-League Leaders #28/44 $.75 $.40
- 1987 Fleer-Limited Edition #26/44 $.75 $.40
- 1987 Fleer-Mini #66 $.75 $.40
- 1987 Kay Bee-Superstars of Baseball #19/33 $1.00 $.50
- 1987 K Mart-25th Anniversary #28 $.75 $.40
- 1987 M & M's-Atar Lineup #11/24 $1.00 $.50
- 1987 Topps #500 $.60 $.30 (9)
- 1987 Topps-All Star #606 $.30 $.15 (2)
- 1987 Topps-Yankees Leaders (w/R. Henderson) #406 $.50 $.25 (6)
- 1988 Donruss #217 $.60 $.30
- 1988 Donruss-MVP #BC-21 $.60 $.30
- 1988 Donruss-Pop-Ups #NNO $1.25 $.65
- 1988 Drake's-Big Hitters #1/33 $10.00 $2.50 $1.25 EX *
- 1988 Drake's-Big Hitters #1/33 $10.00 $1.00 $.50 G *
- 1988 Fantastic Sam's-Baseball Superstars-Discs #9/20 $2.00 $1.00 (2)
- 1988 Fleer #214 $1.00 $.50
- 1988 Fleer-Baseballs Best-Sluggers #26/44 $.75 $.40 (2)
- 1988 Fleer-Superstars #22/44 $.75 $.40
- 1988 K Mart-Memorable Moments #15 $1.00 $.50
- 1988 Rite Aid-Team MVPs #22/33 $1.00 $.50
- 1988 Score-Game Breakers (w/J. Clark) #650 $.30 $.15
- 1988 Score-Box Cut (Cut from box) #NNO $.05 (6)
- 1988 Score-Box Cut (Cut from box) #NNO $.05 VG *
- 1988 Score-Box Panel-All-Star #2/18 $1.50 $.25 $.15 VG *
- 1988 Topps #300 $.60 $.30 (4)
- 1988 Topps-All Star #386 $.30 $.15 (2)
- 1988 Topps-All Star #386 $.30 $.05 $.05 P *
- 1988 Topps-Record Breakers (w/R. Henderson) #2 $.30 $.15 (5)
- 1988 Topps-Box Cut (Cut from box) #NNO $.05 (6) VG *
- 1988 Topps-All-Star Glossy #11/60 $2.00 $1.00
- 1988 Topps-All-Stars-Glossy-Commemorative #2/22 $1.00 $.50 (5)
- 1988 Topps-Mini League Leaders #27 $1.00 $.50 (3)
- 1988 Topps-Stickers (w/O. Smith & E. Whitt) #3 $1.35 $.55 $.30 EX-MT *
- 1988 Topps-Stickers (w/A. Trammell & E. Whitt) #3 $1.20 $.60
- 1988 Topps-UK Minis-American Baseball #45 $1.00 $.50
- 1988 Woolworth-Baseball Highlights #4/33 $1.00 $.50
- 1989 Donruss #74 $.60 $.30 (11)
- 1989 Fleer #258 $.60 $.30 (6)
- 1989 Fleer-For the Record #6/6 $4.00 $2.00 (3)
- 1989 Fleer-League Leaders #25/44 $.75 $.40
- 1989 J.J. Nissen-Super Stars #4/20 $2.00 $1.00 (13)
- 1989 J.J. Nissen-Super Stars #4/20 $2.00 $.80 $.40 (2) EX-MT *
- 1989 J.J. Nissen-Super Stars #4/20 $2.00 $.50 $.25 EX *
- 1989 Topps #700 $.60 $.30
- 1990 Bowman #443 $.60 $.30
- 1990 Bowman-Art Inserts #5 $.60 $.30
- 1990 Classic-Series 3 (Yellow) #T12 $.60 $.30 (3)
- 1990 Collect-A-Books #13/36 $.75 $.40
- 1990 Donruss #190 $.60 $.30 (3)
- 1990 Fleer #447 $.60 $.05 $.05 VG *
- 1990 Fleer-Players of the Decade #626 $.20 $.10
- 1990 K-Mart-Super Stars #17 $1.00 $.50 (4)
- 1990 Leaf #69 $4.00 $2.00
- 1990 Post Cereal #1/30 $1.25 $.15 $.10 VG *
- 1990 Score #1 $.60 $.30 (3)
- 1990 Starline-Long John Silver #28 $.75 $.40
- 1990 Topps #200 $.60 $.30 (3)
- 1990 Upper Deck #191 $1.25 $.65 (2)
- 1990 Upper Deck-Box Cut (Cut from box) #NNO $.05
- 1991 Fleer #673 $.60 $.30
- 1991 Post Cereal #29/30 $1.25 $.65
- 1991 Score #23 $.60 $.30 (2)
- 1991 Upper Deck #354 $.60 $.30 (3)
- 1992 Classic I #T58 $1.00 $.50
- 1992 Confex-Baseball Enquirer-Fun Stuff #62 $1.25 $.65
- 1992 Donruss #596 $.60 $.30 (3)
- 1992 Fleer #237 $.60 $.30 (2)
- 1992 Fleer-Citgo-Performers #16/24 $.60 $.30
- 1992 Leaf #57 $1.00 $.50 (6)
- 1992 Post Cereal #3/30 $1.00 $.50
- 1992 Score #23 $.60 $.30 (2)
- 1992 Stadium Club #420 $1.25 $.65
- 1992 Studio #216 $1.00 $.50
- 1992 Studio-Heritage Series #BC-5 $5.00 $2.50
- 1992 Topps #300 $.60 $.30
- 1992 Topps-Kids #84 $1.00 $.50 (4)
- 1992 Triple Play #159 $1.25 $.65 (2)
- 1992 Ultra #105 $1.25 $.65
- 1992 Upper Deck-All-Star Fanfest-All-Star Heroes #31 $1.50 $.75 (2)
- 1993 Donruss #609 $1.25 $.65 (2)
- 1993 Donruss-Checklist #264 $.30 $.15 (2)
- 1993 Duracell #19/24 $.50 $.25 (2)
- 1993 Flair #249 $3.00 $1.50
- 1993 Fleer-Atlantic #14/25 $1.25 $.65
- 1993 Fun Pack #208 $2.00 $1.00 (2)
- 1993 Hostess Twinkies #28/32 $.75 $.40 (3)
- 1993 Leaf-Gold Leaf Stars (w/F. McGriff) #2/20 $3.00 $1.50 (2)
- 1993 Stadium Club-Broadway Stars (w/D. Gooden) #NNO $4.00 $2.00
- 1993 Studio #193 $1.50 $.75 (2)
- 1993 Topps #32 $1.25 $.65 (2)
- 1993 Triple Play #120 $1.25 $.65 (2)
- 1993 Upper Deck #134 $1.25 $.65
- 1993 Upper Deck-Teammates-Yankee Pride (w/R. Kelly) #47 $.60 $.30
- 1993 Upper Deck-Reggie Jackson Clutch Performers #R14 $3.00 $1.50 (2)
- 1994 Bowman #25 $2.50 $1.25
- 1994 Bowman-Best #45 $3.00 $1.50
- 1994 Collector's Choice #192 $1.25 $.65 (2)
- 1994 Donruss #340 $2.00 $1.00
- 1994 Fleer #239 $2.00 $1.00
- 1994 Fun Pack #123 $3.00 $1.50
- 1994 Leaf-Limited #56 $6.00 $1.80 $.90 EX-MT *
- 1994 Pinnacle #23 $1.25 $.65 (3)
- 1994 Post Cereal #2/30 $1.00 $.50 (9)
- 1994 Select #23 $2.00 $1.00
- 1994 Ultra-Award Winners #2/25 $3.00 $1.50 (2)
- 1994 Upper Deck-Home Field Advantage #290 $1.00 $.50 (3)
- 1995 Bazooka #47 $1.25 $.65
- 1995 Collector's Choice #510 $1.25 $.65
- 1995 Fleer #76 $2.00 $1.00
- 1995 Pinnacle #21 $1.25 $.65
- 1995 SP #175 $2.50 $1.25
- 1995 Studio #3 $2.50 $1.25
- 1995 UC3-In Depth #139 $1.00 $.50
- 1995 Ultra #311 $2.00 $1.00
- 1995 Upper Deck #210 $2.00 $1.00
- 1996 Collector's Choice #237 $1.25 $.65
- 1996 Collector's Choice-Traditional Threads #100 $.60 $.30
- 1996 Pinnacle #99 $1.25 $.65 (2)
- 1996 Pinnacle-Naturals #157 $.60 $.30
- 1996 Topps #185 $1.25 $.65 (3)
- 1996 Upper Deck #154 $2.00 $1.00
- 2000 Upper Deck-Yankees Legends #6 $2.50 $1.25 (2)
- 2002 Leaf-Rookies & Greats-Award Winners #256 $1.50 $.75
- 2006 Greats Of The Game #28 $4.00 $2.00
- 2008 Donruss-Threads #35 $2.00 $1.00 (5)
- 2008 Upper Deck-Heroes #125 $2.50 $1.25 (2)
- 2008 Upper Deck-Heroes (w/W. Boggs) #176 $2.50 $1.25
- 2008 Upper Deck-Heroes (w/R. Jackson & D. Winfield) #190 $2.50 $1.25 (2)
- 2011 Los Angeles Dodgers-Season Schedule #NNO $.50 $.25
- 2011 Topps-Heritage #217 $2.00 $1.00
- 2011 Upper Deck-Goodwin Champions #16 $1.25 $.65
Cards marked with an * are less than Near Mint. Scans available.
Visit the Don Mattingly Gallery.
Back to Card Shop. Back to home page.